Made as part of a GB News documentary entitled Yookay: How Immigration Changed a Nation, the clip features Edginton ambushing a young, autistic black man on the street, before questioning him about his relationship to Britain. Edginton asks him whether he considers it to be his home, what he thinks about several historic British figures, such as Alfred the Great and the Duke of Wellington, and what he thinks about ‘British values’.
It seems the interview’s purpose was to humiliate the interviewee, and to prove that demographic change has done great harm to any coherent sense of Britishness. But if those were the aims, it fails miserably. The interviewee comes across as decent, good-natured and likeable.
He might not know much about Alfred the Great or the Duke of Wellington – which, to be fair, is probably true for many Brits. And he acknowledges that defining British values is a ‘difficult one’, which is true given the phrase has been kicked around as a political football for several decades. But he’s clearly proud to call Britain his home and loves living here.
In short, the young lad came across well, while Edginton came across as supercilious and arch. The interview has since come in for a lot of criticism. GB News presenter Martin Daubney publicly took issue with it and praised the interviewee. Such was the interview’s cynicism and bad faith that even former leader of the English Defence League (EDL) Tommy Robinson defended the interviewee as someone who had ‘no hate for Britain’.
Some among the Very Online right, however, seized on the clip as evidence that non-white Britons, including those who are born here, are not truly British. This doesn’t just reveal a certain nastiness on their part, but also how far removed they are from decent mainstream opinion.
Take Harrison Pitt, senior policy fellow at the Restore Britain movement. He described this lifelong south Londoner as ‘unassimilated’, presumably due to his failure to answer questions on British history. Pitt even claimed that the interviewee ‘associates “Britain” with its most conquered, colonised, YooKay areas’, which is reading a lot into the fact that he lists his favourite parts of the UK as Stockwell, Brixton and Clapham, places that are local to him. If Pitt thinks a knowledge of Anglo-Saxon history and residence in the presumably non-colonised English countryside are markers of assimilation, then that’s likely to make the majority of Brits ‘unassimilated’.
There is certainly a need to have a robust debate on the impact of state-supported multiculturalism and demographic change on modern Britain. But this can be done without referring to south London as ‘conquered’ territory and accusing a young black Briton who considers the UK to be his home of being ‘unassimilated’.
This attempt at gotcha-style journalism was a terrible misjudgement. It attempted to ridicule a friendly and humorous young man who clearly harbours no ideologically hostile feelings towards Britain – all in order to run Britain down. That it failed to do so is down to this young Brit himself. Amid so much pessimism, polarisation and racial grievance, he is to be treasured, not scorned.
Rakib Ehsan is the author of Beyond Grievance: What the Left Gets Wrong about Ethnic Minorities, which is available to order on Amazon.
Who funds spiked? You do
We are funded by you. And in this era of cancel culture and advertiser boycotts, we rely on your donations more than ever. Seventy per cent of our revenue comes from our readers’ donations – the vast majority giving just £5 per month. If you make a regular donation – of £5 a month or £50 a year – you can become a and enjoy:
–Ad-free reading
–Exclusive events
–Access to our comments section
It’s the best way to keep spiked going – and growing. Thank you!
