The first wave of reactions to the shocking victory by Zohran Mamdani in the New York City Democratic mayoral primary included many individuals and companies pledging to flee the city rather than live under the rule of a self-declared national socialist. Indeed, given the undoubtedly confiscatory tax rates, onerous regulations, and openly anti-Israel policies that Mamdani has promised to pursue, including the arrest of Israeli Prime Minister Bibi Netanyahu if he sets foot in the Big Apple, the exodus from blue to red states already underway is bound to accelerate if the AOC- and Bernie Sanders-backed New York assemblyman prevails in the November general election.
Mamdani’s nomination has, to say the least, placed nervous Democratic leaders in a tenuous position in which they will be attacked whether they endorse Mamdani or not. Sen. Chuck Schumer (D-NY) and Rep. Hakeem Jeffries (D-NY) have both danced around the question. Jeffries says he has not committed to an endorsement because he doesn’t know Mamdani personally, as if that actually matters in party politics. Schumer defended Mamdani from GOP attacks he called “disgusting” but has not endorsed him, knowing he will be damned if he does and damned if he doesn’t. If he publicly declares his support for the mayoral nominee, he will be vilified for backing a socialist-communist. If he does not endorse, he will face accusations of being insufficiently progressive by Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-NY), who appears increasingly likely to challenge Schumer when he seeks re-election in 2028.
The problem is that most of the damage to the Democratic brand has already been done. Whether he becomes the next New York mayor or not, just the fact that Mamdani could win a majority of primary voters in the nation’s biggest city signals to the country that the Democrats, far from moderating after their blowout loss last November, have doubled down on socialism, a devastating label, especially in New York, the epicenter of capitalism. Thus, the flight from blue New York in recent years, as from California, to the low-tax havens of Florida and Texas, among others, is all but certain to accelerate and change the electoral face of the nation. Unbeknownst to many, the exodus has already been underway for years.
A Blue Nation Heads Red
The numbers are stark. From pandemic-plagued 2020 to 2024, California, New York, and Illinois each lost more than 100,000 residents. Florida and Texas, meanwhile, both gained some 2 million new inhabitants. California has suffered a net loss of population for three years running after being a perpetual magnet for newcomers since it gained statehood in 1850. And with the calamities of homelessness, unchecked natural disasters, skyrocketing cost of living, and gross mismanagement, the pattern does not figure to reverse anytime soon. In fact, that general trend has taken hold over the entirety of the 21st century. In the last 20 years, nine million more people have moved from blue to red states than from red to blue.
The upshot of this exodus is a potentially game-changing alteration to congressional apportionment and the Electoral College come 2030, when the next census is conducted. The American Redistricting Project predicts that California is on track to lose three House seats — and three electoral votes — after the 2030 reapportionment, while New York could lose two seats. Other blue states such as Minnesota, Oregon, Rhode Island, and Illinois are also in danger of losing a seat. Meanwhile, Texas and Florida are each projected to gain a whopping four seats. Idaho and Utah will also likely add an additional seat.
All in all, red states are projected to add 10 congressional seats and electoral votes while blue states will likely lose nine ahead of the 2032 election. With both Florida and Ohio having now been transformed from toss-up states to ruby red, Republicans would be in a stronger position to win presidential races and control of Congress than at any time in memory. Until 2016, Democrats held an enormous advantage in big states with a combined 104 reliable electoral votes in California, New York, and Illinois, while the GOP could rely only on Texas’ 36 votes. But following the 2020 census and the rightward turn in Florida and Ohio, the big-state numbers figure to be substantially different by 2032, when Republicans should control a combined 93 Electoral College votes in Florida, Texas, and Ohio compared to 99 for Democrats in California, New York, and Illinois. Remember also that the margins for Kamala Harris in that trio of reliably blue states were considerably lower than in past presidential contests.
All in all, red states – not counting the purplish battlegrounds of Pennsylvania, Michigan, and Wisconsin, formerly known as the “blue wall” – could well flip enough congressional seats and electoral votes to swing close presidential and congressional elections they used to lose. In addition, with the blue wall having crumbled in 2016 and 2024, Democrats can hardly count on the 44 electoral votes in that trio of heartland states like they did before Hillary Clinton and Kamala Harris lost all of them.
Leave Your Liberalism Behind in New York
Despite its pride in attracting so many new residents, Floridians are not necessarily embracing the flight to their Sunshine State. In an article entitled, “I fled NYC for Florida — sorry, Mamdani-fearing Democrats, we’re full!” a man who moved to Florida from blue Connecticut told the New York Post, “’I’m seriously concerned’ about Mamdani flight … ‘His socialist policies — like rent freezes and free everything — are exactly the kind of insanity I left behind.’”
“If they move here, they better keep their blue votes at home,” his wife added, “and learn to appreciate the true reasons why Florida is so amazing.” A lifelong Floridian living on its west coast worried about those fleeing blue states “not simply to build a better life, but often bringing with them political agendas that risk altering the character of our communities.” Or as another Floridian added, “Bring your money, leave your liberal views.”
Elections have consequences, and even though many liberals who see a Mayor Mamdani as a bridge too far might bring their liberalism to their new home in red America. One can envision future generations looking back on the 2020s as a pivot point where a majority blue nation turned red. People vote not just by pulling a lever in the voting booth but with their feet. And the blue-to-red exodus is undoubtedly scaring the bejesus out of Democrats long accustomed to holding an electoral advantage, but who are now bracing for their new status as America’s minority party.
