The Rise, Fall, and Potential Rebirth of Tim Walz

Failing upwards is always an option.

In a surprising twist of political fate yesterday, January 5, Minnesota Governor Tim Walz announced that he would not be seeking re-election for a third term as chief executive of the Land of 10,000 Lakes. The crushing weight of potential fraud in his state appears to be the impetus behind his stepping down. And yet, within hours of the campaign resignation, chatter began with a raucous chorus that Mr. Walz might well be on his way to Washington, DC. Just not necessarily in the position that many expected.

Shifting Attention

“I can’t give a political campaign my all,” Walz said to the press. “Every minute that I spend defending my own political interests would be a minute I can’t spend defending the people of Minnesota against the criminals who prey on our generosity and the cynics who want to prey on our differences.”

The criminals are presumably those accused of currently engaging in fraud via daycare and health centers. And the cynics in this case would then be those who are angered with the potential billions in taxpayer dollars being fraudulently claimed. Ignoring just for a moment why “cynics” would be the subject of ire if actual fraud is taking place, Governor Walz seems to be saying that a lengthy, and no doubt difficult, campaign would be a distraction from setting the Minnesota ship back on course. And in this instance, he has a point.

However, if the events that surrounded his announcement come to fruition, this will not be the end of his political career.

Walz – The Ultimate Electoral Distraction

The New York Times related:

“More than 90 people have been charged with felonies in the federal fraud cases to date and at least 60 have been convicted. The vast majority of defendants are of Somali origin, and many Republicans accused Mr. Walz and fellow Democrats of failing to respond forcefully to red flags about theft in state-run programs in part because Somali Americans are an influential voting bloc for Democrats.”

When even the Old Gray Lady is willing to note that a Walz campaign could politically tarnish his party’s brand, one can be sure that the notion has already entered the public zeitgeist. Indeed, running for any office with this shadow of fraud over his head could prove a contagious disaster for fellow Democrats. And yet, the pull of power is strong, and the governor may have other options.

It is widely reported that prior to his announcement, Walz broke bread with four-term Senator Amy Klobuchar to discuss his plans. Last elected in 2024, Klobuchar has a number of years left in her current role; while she handily won all four US Senate elections, the margin of victory has been narrowing in recent years.

A tentative offer to Walz to step aside and back her could prove a winning move.

As Minnesota House Speaker Lisa Demuth, a Republican, theorized in a social media post, “If Tim Walz is going to handpick Klobuchar, Minnesotans deserve to know what she promised him. Senator? Something else? Despite any shady backroom deals cut by Walz, voters will decide who is our state’s next Governor and Senator.”

In fact, a number of media outlets are reporting that their sources confirm Klobuchar is eying the governor’s mansion. Walz’ full-throated endorsement may carry a lot of weight in getting her over the finish line. What is such a gift worth?

Do the Math

While the varied chatter of the political class is often best taken with a shovel of salt, the power math for the Democratic Party makes sense. After all, Tim Walz is currently damaged goods, and his gubernatorial race could have been a little too close for comfort. Senator Klobuchar has a solid chance of winning the contest, and by appointing Walz to finish out her term, leaves the party with two nationally recognized figures in office.

As former British Prime Minister Harold Wilson is reported to have said, “A week is a long time in politics.”  Should Klobuchar throw her hat in the ring for governor and appoint Walz to finish out her term, that gives the current governor four more years to act like the proverbial phoenix and rehabilitate his political reputation.